Sunday, October 15, 2023


Banks Keep Financing Coal Despite Their Net-Zero Pledges

In recent years, world leaders and leading environmentalists have predicted “the end of coal,” with charts showing how the world’s most polluting fossil fuel has plummeted in use and production in the U.S. and Europe over the last few decades.

Yet coal remains the world’s single largest power source, generating 36% of global power in 2022. And its use has actually increased in Europe and the U.S. in recent years, with U.S. coal production rising almost 8% from 2020 to 2021 and almost 3% from 2021 to 2022. U.S. coal consumption increased 14.5% from 2020 to 2021. Carbon dioxide from coal use is responsible for about 40% of global greenhouse gas emissions from fossil fuels.

That surge in activity would not be possible without financing by banks and other financial institutions. Six global banks — Barclays PLC, JPMorgan Chase & Co., Bank of America Corp., Citibank, Wells Fargo & Co. and Mitsubishi UFJ Financial Group Inc. — have plowed $83.8 billion into 10 parent companies that operate coal plants since 2016. Overall, financial institutions have injected $166 billion into that coal network since 2016, according to the Sierra Club’s Fossil-Free Finance Campaign.

Most of the banks have made high-profile net-zero commitments, such as joining the Net Zero Banking Alliance, whose members pledged to stop financing fossil fuel projects. They often tout their climate action plans in speeches and press releases, emphasizing that they will not finance the building of a new coal plant.

But banks such as JPMorgan and Citibank continue to finance fossil fuels, including the coal sector, via a major loophole that exploits the difference between project financing and corporate financing. They may not be lending money to a specific mine or coal plant, but they generously finance the companies building and operating coal plants. In total, 96% of the world’s 60 largest banks’ financing to the fossil fuel industry from 2016 to 2022 was described as general purpose corporate financing, while only 4% was described as project financing, according to the Sierra Club’s “Banking on Climate Chaos” report.

Coal remains the world’s single largest power source, and its use has increased in Europe and the U.S. in recent years.
“It’s an extremely common loophole for many banks,” said April Merleaux, research manager on the climate and energy team at the Rainforest Action Network. She added that another loophole — the lack of explicit policies to limit corporate financing to companies responsible for maintaining and operating coal plants — allows banks to keep financing coal-fired power plants. “It gives them wiggle room to finance a company developing coal power,” Merleaux said. “These plants still require the production of fossil fuels, and this financing delays really serious transition plans that take into account the people across the value chain.”

For example, JPMorgan Chase announced in February 2020 that it will not finance many coal-related enterprises, including coal-fired power plants. Yet since then, it has continued to finance energy companies that own coal plants. In April 2023, it co-financed the issuance of 650 million euros in bonds by French energy giant Engie SA, which generates electrical power through its coal plants. In March 2022, it co-financed a $5.4 billion revolving credit facility for German energy giant RWE AG, which recently made headlines for dismantling a wind farm to make room for an open-pit lignite coal mine in the western region of the German state of North Rhine-Westphalia.

Among major American banks, PNC Bank has also been outspoken about its climate commitments ever since it won praise almost a decade ago for announcing that it would stop financing coal companies that rely on mountaintop removal. “The climate crisis requires PNC — and all institutions, from governments to corporations to NGOs (nongovernmental organizations) and beyond — to work together to apply their expertise and resources in ways that can truly move the needle,” said Lora Phillips, PNC senior vice president and director of environmental, social and governance, in a new release. “PNC is committed to taking action right now on those areas we can control, and to laying a solid foundation for the work that is still to come.”

That strong rhetoric didn’t stop the bank in August from extending a $140 million credit facility to Indiana-based Hallador Energy Co., which owns the state’s second-largest coal producer. One of its coal-fired power plants in the town of Merom, Indiana, was set to retire in 2023, but its life was extended when a crypto mining company, AboutBit LLC, announced that it would buy power generated at the plant. In a December 2022 filing with the Securities and Exchange Commission, Hallador said, “We expect cash from operations generated primarily by our expected higher coal margins in 2023 to fund our capital expenditures and our debt service.” The Merom plant has been cited for violations of the Clean Air Act, according to a consent order with the EPA requiring it to reduce emissions of sulfur dioxide and nitrogen oxides. When AboutBit’s owner was asked about critics’ claims that the five-year deal would keep a polluting coal plan open, he replied, “It’s 100 percent correct.”

Coal production is increasing for several reasons, principally due to recent spikes in the prices of natural gas and other fuels, which has forced some countries and regions of the U.S. to use coal as a cheaper alternative. In addition, as the International Energy Agency reported, the world’s coal consumption will remain at elevated levels “in the absence of stronger efforts to accelerate the transition to clean energy.”

******************************************************

A study claims heat suppresses economic growth. It falls apart under scrutiny

Climate change hurts the economy, according to a celebrated 2012 paper by economists Melissa Dell, Benjamin Jones and Benjamin Olken. That paper is in the top 1% of all academic economics publications by citation count, and it has received glowing coverage in the media. The authors teach at Harvard, Northwestern and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, respectively, and have received some of the highest awards in the profession. I took a closer look at their study, and it doesn’t hold up.

The study claims that higher temperatures suppress economic growth in poor countries. The claim falls apart when you look at their definitions. The authors study the period 1961-2003 and assign each country a binary designation as “poor” or “rich” based on whether their per capita gross domestic product was below or above the median for countries in 1960.

But some countries faced drastic changes in fortune at the time.

South Korea is “poor,” according to the authors. In reality, it was very poor in the early 1960s and then became very wealthy. When I simply reclassified South Korea as poor from 1961-76 and rich from 1977-2003, the study’s results nearly disappeared. When I allowed classifications of all countries to change when they moved either above or below median GDP per capita, the results disappeared completely. Any study with results that collapse after such a simple specification change shouldn’t be published in a peer-reviewed academic journal.

I also found that unusual economic circumstances greatly influenced countries’ results. Per capita GDP in Rwanda dropped by 63% in 1994, the year of the genocide. That year happened to be warmer than average, tricking the model into showing that high temperatures cause GDP to fall. Dropping 16 unusual country/year observations out of 4,924 eliminated the main effect the study reported. Other seemingly arbitrary aspects of their technique, when changed, weakened or eliminated their results.

I extended their data from 2003 to 2017 and added additional countries to the sample. I found again that correctly classifying countries as poor or rich eliminated their results. Going back to their original data source, I discovered that monthly temperatures are available, although they used only annual temperature data. If high temperatures really reduce GDP growth, it seems likely that this effect would be greatest in the warmest months of the year. I found no evidence to support that hypothesis in the original or the extended data. I also used a completely different set of data on GDP by country and found no effect of temperature on growth.

Climate activists need evidence that high temperatures reduce economic growth to advance their policies. Responsible economists have found that high temperatures have only small effects on the level of GDP. If temperatures rise as the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change expects—assuming no CO2 mitigation at all—then according to responsible economists, global GDP in 2100 will be about 2.6% lower than if there was no temperature increase. With normal economic growth, GDP per capita in 2100 will be five times today’s level. A 2.6% reduction in GDP in 2100 would mean GDP growth of 4.9 times instead of 5—hardly a catastrophe. But if researchers claim to show that higher temperatures will affect the rate of GDP growth, then the effects of heat by the year 2100 could be significant. That is why pro-climate researchers are so desperate to find an effect of temperature on growth.

Econ Journal Watch, which published my debunking, contacted the authors and gave them an opportunity to respond to my work. They declined. It is astonishing that eminent economists, in universities with vast resources available to marshal evidence, chose to ignore my critique. But the mainstream media will ignore anything that reveals the weaknesses of climate research, and academic journals will continue to publish shoddy research that confirms the dogma of climate hysteria.

**************************************************

Extraordinary Costs Of Green Energy Creeping Slowly Into Public Awareness

A key claim of the green energy movement has long been that the intermittent “renewables” — wind and solar — provide the cheapest form of energy. Therefore, the advocates say, just build enough wind turbines and solar panels, convert all use of energy to electricity, and sit back and enjoy a future of affordable energy without adverse environmental consequences.

Meanwhile a key theme at this blog has been exposing the incompetence and chicanery of the claims of low cost for electricity from wind and sun. Although it may often seem as if nobody is listening, I reassure myself that when the full costs of wind and solar electricity eventually get exposed, the people will catch on and not allow themselves to be impoverished.

Over in Europe, it looks like enough of the costs have now gotten exposed to cause the beginning of a public awakening. In August I had a post on how the costs of “green” energy were starting to change the “net zero” debate in the UK. Now, add to that report the results of the elections this past weekend in Germany and Luxembourg. In both countries, parties now standing at least somewhat against the green transition scored gains, while Greens lost ground. The process of ultimate political transformation looks to be long and slow; but I have faith that reality will eventually win out.

First, a short refresher on the claims of green energy advocates that the wind and sun provide the cheapest power. If you only read this blog, or other climate skeptic sources, you may find it incredible that anyone could believe such assertions. But you must remember that the self-designated climate advocates repeat these claims to themselves endlessly in an echo chamber where no one ever pushes back. Eventually, it appears, they come to believe that the claims are true.

And thus, here is my blog post from August 16, 2022, reporting on a Soho Forum debate on the energy future, between Steven Koonin and Andrew Dessler. Dessler, arguing for a future of wind and solar power, had as his main contention that those are cheaper than the fossil fuel alternatives, and therefore they will inevitably sweep the fossil fuel infrastructure away. Although he is some kind of leader in the climate alarm movement, Dessler appeared to have no clue that there was any counter-information to his contentions about the costs of wind and solar power. In support of his position, Dessler used as his main metric the “Levelized Cost of Energy” (LCOE) as published by investment bank Lazard. The LCOE metric is ridiculously flawed, and should not fool anybody, but seems to have fooled not just Dessler but also the entire green energy movement (and for that matter the entire Democratic Party and the President of the United States).

And nothing about LCOE and fraudulent advocacy based on it is going away. Long after the Soho Forum debate last August, Lazard went right ahead and came out with a new and updated Report in April titled “2023 Levelized Cost of Energy+.”

You can see right there that the cost (measured by LCOE) of solar PV is $24-96/MWh, onshore wind is even less at $24-75/MWh, and the cheapest fossil fuel alternative is combined cycle natural gas at $39-101/MWh. So wind and solar are cheaper — QED! But, as I wrote in my August 16, 2022 post:

[A]n LCOE calculation completely omits the dominant costs of generating reliable electricity using mostly or entirely wind and solar generators. These dominant costs are the costs of energy storage and/or backup, the costs of overbuilding, and the costs of additional transmission.

Meanwhile over in Europe, I doubt that many people are abandoning the green movement based on complex spreadsheet calculations of the costs involved. Rather, most of them are starting to face up to reality because of some combination of skyrocketing electricity bills and plans to ban gas heat and internal combustion cars.

The BBC reports here on the results of yesterday’s regional elections in the German states of Bavaria and Hesse. The swings in voter preferences were not huge, but still enough to be meaningful on the climate issue. For example, in Bavaria the BBC reports that the long-dominant CSU got 36.7% of the vote, and a second conservative party, the Free Voters (Freie Währen) expanded to 15%, while the Greens “slipped slightly” to 15% and the SPD (party of Chancellor Olaf Scholz) got only a “catastrophic” 8%. The BBC has this to say about the issues in the Bavarian election:

In an unusually ferocious campaign in Bavaria, conservatives and right-wingers railed against Berlin's plans to phase out fossil fuel boilers and high levels of migration.

While this was not a one-issue referendum on green energy, still it is clear from the results that opposing green energy in at least some respects was definitely a positive rather than a negative among the electorate.

In Luxembourg, the swings were also mostly small, but included a gain for the conservatives matched with a dramatic loss for the Greens. Bloomberg reports on October 8 that the long-time ruling coalition of Democrats, Socialists and Greens got “toppled.” In a parliament of 60, the Conservatives upped their total to 21 seats, while the Greens went from 9 seats to just 4. The result is likely to be a governing coalition of the conservatives with other parties, but excluding the Greens, which could mean a significant shift in green energy policies.

Back here in the U.S., the Biden administration continues with its wrecking ball approach to destroying our energy economy. But as Europe is showing us, small changes voter preferences can change that quickly after the next election.

*************************************************

Voice to climate: Can you hear me?

Judith Sloan

The [Australian] Prime Minister has flagged that, post the Voice referendum, his government will turn its full attention to the decarbonisation of the economy and the prospect of Australia becoming an renewable energy superpower.

You really have to wonder whether Albo is smoking something if he thinks that moving from the toxic and divisive issue of the Voice to the fantasy world of climate action is a good idea. But if you live in the world of the vibe, one vibe is as good as another.

By contrast, most of us are living in the real world, wondering how we can cover the mortgage and the bills, getting the kids to school on time and thinking about what’s for dinner. Prosaic stuff to be sure, but beautiful thoughts about identity politics and climate change are generally back of mind, if at all.

To be sure, surveys tell us that people are concerned about climate change, which is not altogether surprising given the unrelenting and misleading conflation of weather and climate change perpetrated by all the mainstream media outlets. Several hot days in Sydney – climate change. Limited flooding in parts of Victoria – climate change. Bushfire warnings for parts of the east coast – climate change.

The implicit message is that Australia alone – or should that be NSW or the city of Sydney – can affect the pace of climate change and therefore reduce the incidence of unwelcome weather events. Most school students – OK, some, OK a few – would realise that this is a complete non sequitur as only global action counts.

But what the surveys also reveal is that, notwithstanding people’s concerns about climate change – economists call this elicitation bias or wanting to sound worthy – when it comes to bearing any additional financial burden to act on climate change, there is a marked reluctance to pay any significant price at all. The recent 20-per-cent rise in electricity prices, for instance, is well above the rate of increase that people are happy to pay for the sake of doing something about the climate.

The real paradox is why Albo thinks it’s an attractive political idea to emphasise the energy transition and the exciting world that lies ahead. Let’s face it, it hasn’t been going well, what with delays in the commissioning of new renewable projects, the growing opposition to the construction of new transmission lines and, let’s not forget, the disastrous Snowy 2.0 project. If I were to run a book on when Snowy 2.0 will be fully up and running, I’m not sure I would have too many bets on this decade.

I could do a similar thing with offshore wind installations, as the economics of these projects overseas deteriorate to the point that most investment is currently stalled. Rising costs, worker and equipment shortages and higher interest rates are an uncongenial mix. The UK government ran a tender for new offshore wind projects recently and there was not a single bid because the strike price was set too low.

The rent-seekers in this space in the US have declared that a doubling of the prices they receive is now necessary to make offshore wind a viable investment. This is another counter to the ludicrous proposition that renewables are the cheapest way to generate electricity, something to which Albo still clings.

The one bright light in the energy transition has been the rapid growth in rooftop solar by households and some businesses. This is seen as one means to save on electricity bills in the context of very limited options. According to the Clean Energy Regulator, ‘Australian households and businesses continue to install rooftop solar at world leading rates. 1.6 gigawatts of capacity from almost 160,000 rooftop systems were added in the first half of 2023. Three gigawatts would bring the amount of rooftop solar capacity added to the grid close to the 2021 record of 3.2 GW’.

There are two reasons for mentioning this. The first is that households’ fondness for their rooftop solar panels often morphs into their support for renewable energy more generally – something recognised by state politicians, in particular. The continued subsidisation of rooftop solar installations, albeit at reduced levels, is partly explained by the ability to cadge additional votes.

Secondly, the unexpected rise in rooftop solar is playing havoc with the economics of large-scale solar installations. For several hours during the day, electricity prices can be deeply negative. Those large-scale solar installations are in effect competing with rooftop solar.

To be sure, most of the large-scale installations have been backed by power purchase agreements or similar (mainly from state governments) which guarantee the investors/operators certain prices. But the reality is that large-scale solar is looking like a particularly bad investment bet at the moment save a substantial step-up in the prices being offered. It is already clear that the expected roll-out of new projects has significantly slowed this year.

Again as the Clean Energy Regulator notes, ‘it was a quiet first half of the year for new large-scale renewable energy investment (including wind) commitments. We’ve downgraded out expectations and now expect 2023 investment may not reach three gigawatts’.

Even the deep-green Australian Energy Market Operator doesn’t expect the 82 per cent renewable energy target by 2030 to be met. No doubt, Albo will have to downplay these real world realities.

And he definitely won’t want to mention the fact that the Victorian government is now propping up not one, but two coal-fired power stations in the anticipation that its energy transition plans are in tatters. The only feasible alternative is to hand out hundreds of millions of taxpayer dollars – although precise figures are kept under wraps – so they don’t close down. The NSW government will start handing out big bucks to the owner of Eraring to keep that plant going.

Let’s not forget that the cost curve for these plants resembles a bathtub. Towards the end of their lifespans, the costs increase dramatically particularly when they are used to back up intermittent renewable energy, something for which they are not designed.

He might also want to avoid talking too much about the much-vaunted green hydrogen revolution, something for which other rent-seekers are keen to hoover up as much government money as possible. It’s becoming clear that, at best, hydrogen will play a niche role in the energy transition.

Using intermittent energy to power electrolysers to produce hydrogen is inherently inefficient and the problems of transport and bespoke infrastructure just add to the costs. The winners are likely to be close to the demand and blue hydrogen (made from gas) has much more going for it in terms of costs than green hydrogen.

The idea that Australia will become an energy superpower on the basis of green hydrogen is fanciful notwithstanding the ongoing enthusiasm of Twiggy. It’s a bit like the underground electricity cable from the Northern Territory to Singapore – ain’t going to happen.

Albo may need to move onto another vibe – it’s just not clear what it will be.

***************************************

My other blogs. Main ones below

http://dissectleft.blogspot.com (DISSECTING LEFTISM )

http://edwatch.blogspot.com (EDUCATION WATCH)

http://pcwatch.blogspot.com (POLITICAL CORRECTNESS WATCH)

http://australian-politics.blogspot.com (AUSTRALIAN POLITICS)

http://snorphty.blogspot.com/ (TONGUE-TIED)

http://jonjayray.com/blogall.html More blogs

*****************************************

Friday, October 13, 2023



Antarctica's melting ice shelves have unleashed 7.5 TRILLION tonnes of water into the oceans since 1997, study finds

Here we go again! La de da de da! Once more there is absolutely no mention of the subsurface vulcanism that is common at both poles. In Antarctica it is primarily Western Antactica where the volcanoes are. And if you had a volcano under your bottom you would melt too.

You don't need to read the confused journalism excerpted below. The graph is pretty clear that it is primarily West Antarctica where the ice loss has occurred. The report emphasizes ice loss from the Ronne, Getz and Ross ice-shelves. All are in Western Antarctica, with the biggest loss being at the Getz, which is the most Westerly of the three.

Sorry boys! The melting is due to random fluctuations in volcanic activity, not global warming


image from https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/10/12/15/76470079-12622893-Using_100_000_satellite_images_taken_over_20_years_the_researche-m-56_1697120287996.jpg

Over the last 25 years, Antarctica's melting ice sheets have released a staggering 7.5 trillion tonnes of water into the ocean, a study has revealed.

Analyzing over 100,000 satellite radar images, researchers from the University of Leeds discovered a steady erosion of the continent's ice sheets, with over 40 per shrinking between 1997 and 2021.

While some ice sheets did grow in size during this time, the data revealed that a third have now lost more than 30 per cent of their initial mass - unleashing vast quantities of freshwater in the process.

Worryingly, scientists say this vast release of fresh water could threaten to destabilise ocean currents and contribute to global sea level rise.

What's more, human-induced climate change means that ice melt will continue to happen faster in the future, the experts warn....

While the Western side is exposed to warm waters which erode the ice shelves from below, East Antarctica is protected by a band of colder water close to the shore.

Overall, 59 trillion tonnes of water have been added to the continent's ice shelves since 1975. However, this was offset by the 67 trillion tonnes that were lost.

The biggest losses took place at the Getz Ice Shelf, which lost 1.9 trillion tonnes of water.

For perspective, one trillion tones of ice would make a cube more than six miles (10 km) in every direction - more than half a mile taller than Mt Everest!

Of this loss, 95 per cent was caused by melting and five per cent by 'calving', where large chunks of ice break off into the ocean.

Meanwhile, on the other side of Antarctica, the Amery Ice Shelf gained 1.2 trillion tonnes of ice due to the colder waters surrounding it.

Dr Benjamin Davison, who led the study, says this evidence points to a distinct change in the Antarctic ice.

'We expected most ice shelves to go through cycles of rapid, but short-lived shrinking, then to regrow slowly,' Dr Davidson said.

'Instead, we see that almost half of them are shrinking with no sign of recovery.'

Dr Davidson and his colleagues believe that this change has been brought about by human-induced global warming.

If the increased rate of melting were due to natural factors such as a variation in climate patterns, there would have also been evidence of ice regrowth in the typically warmer west.

The Getz Ice Shelf, where the worst of the ice melt has occurred, shed 1.9 trillion tonnes of water into the southern ocean over 25 years

Recent research revealed that the ice surrounding Antarctica, known as the sea ice extent, was at a historic low in September measuring less than 6.5 million square miles (17 million sq km), according to the US's National Snow and Ice Data Center.

While this may seem vast it is, in fact, 580,000 square miles (1.5 million sq km) less than average for September - an area equivalent to five times the size of the British Isles.

******************************************************

Critics Assail Biden’s ‘War on American Energy’ on National Energy Appreciation Day

Sen. Cynthia Lummis sponsored a resolution establishing the first-ever National Energy Appreciation Day, and the Wyoming Republican had much to say about American energy at a panel discussion marking the occasion Wednesday.

“As [the Biden] administration continues to put our domestic energy producers on the back burner with its war on American energy, it is essential that we pause to recognize and celebrate their invaluable contributions to our daily lives that we so often take for granted,” Lummis explained in a press statement.

National Energy Appreciation Day is slated for the first Wednesday in October, which is observed as National Energy Awareness Month in the U.S.

Mandy Gunasekara, director of the Center for Energy and Conservation at the Independent Women’s Forum, had the idea for Wednesday’s panel discussion, dubbed “American Energy for Prosperity” and held at The Heritage Foundation in Washington. (The Daily Signal is the news outlet of The Heritage Foundation.)

“Let’s take some time to recognize the fact that we flipped the switch,” Gunasekara said. “The lights, generally speaking, come on.”

The country’s front-line energy workers are the backbone of American energy, she said, noting they power our economy, working “through the night to ensure that there are no disruptions.”

“It is appropriate that we celebrate our front-line energy workers, acknowledge their importance in our economy, and do this annually,” said Lummis, whose state is rich in energy supplies. “Everyone who’s involved in the energy business is keeping America strong. It is a national security issue. It is an American independence issue. It’s a freedom issue.”

President Joe Biden’s administration has been striving to eliminate the fossil-fuel industry in the United States in the name of mitigating climate change. But even “if we got rid of all the fossil fuels in the United States, this would only make a difference of two-tenths of one degree Celsius by the year 2100,” said Diana Furchtgott-Roth, director of the Center for Energy, Climate, and Environment at The Heritage Foundation.

“Over the past 15 years, the United States’ emissions of carbon have gone down by 1,000 million metric tons because of our use of clean natural gas,” she said.

Meanwhile, “China’s emissions have gone up by 5,000 million metric tons [over the past 15 years],” Furchtgott-Roth said, “because they are making the solar panels and the wind turbines with coal-fired power plants.” And the Biden administration’s energy policies give more economic power to China.

Biden’s first executive order revoked the presidential permit granted to the Keystone XL pipeline, halting construction of the natural gas infrastructure. The Keystone XL pipeline was intended to supply U.S. natural gas to markets across North America.

Biden’s determination to shut down American energy production has had ripple effects on the geopolitical stage. “We have China helping support Russia in their war against Ukraine,” Lummis said. “We are buying Chinese technology for wind and solar infrastructure. We buy their batteries, their wind technology, their solar technology. Then they take our money and join with Russia to fight our friends [in Ukraine].”

*******************************************

Global fossil fuel use and CO2 emissions to rise through 2050, EIA projects

"Energy trade of fossil fuels will continue to evolve as emerging economies demand more energy and the world continues to adapt to current geopolitical events."

In our International Energy Outlook 2023 (IEO2023), we project that global energy-related CO2 emissions will increase by 2050 in a number of IEO2023 cases as global population growth and higher living standards push growth in energy consumption beyond advances in energy efficiency.

In all IEO2023 cases, we expect global primary energy consumption to increase through 2050. Our expectations of global population growth, increased regional manufacturing, and higher living standards indicate that global energy consumption will grow faster than advances in energy efficiency. Non-fossil fuel-based resources, including nuclear and renewables, produce more energy through 2050, but in most of the IEO2023 cases we examined, that growth is not sufficient to reduce global energy-related CO2 emissions under current laws and regulations.

In our IEO2023, we explore long-term world energy trends and present an outlook for energy markets through 2050. We use different scenarios, called cases, to understand how varying assumptions about technological advancement and economic growth affect energy trends. The IEO2023 Reference case—which serves as a baseline, or benchmark—and six side cases consider only the laws and regulations adopted through March 2023. The six side cases in IEO2023 explore differing assumptions of economic growth, crude oil prices, and technology costs.

U.S. projections in IEO2023 are the published projections in the Annual Energy Outlook 2023 (AEO2023), which assumed that U.S. laws and regulations as of November 2022 remain unchanged.

***********************************************

Renewables funds see record outflows as rising rates, costs hit shares

Investors ditched renewable energy funds at the fastest rate on record in the three months to end-September as cleaner energy shares took a beating from higher interest rates and soaring material costs, which are squeezing profit margins.

Renewable energy funds globally suffered a net outflow of US$1.4-billion in the July-September quarter, the biggest ever quarterly outflow, according to LSEG Lipper data.

However, the outflows only partially reversed the trend for the first half of 2023 when investors added a net US$3.36-billion, the data showed.

The sector’s total assets under management now stand at US$65.4-billion, a 23-per-cent decline from end-June, according to the data.

Investors have been exiting traditional energy funds, too, but the rate has slowed – net outflows reached US$438-million in the last quarter compared with US$3.32-billion in the previous three months.

Renewable energy firms with high growth potential are vulnerable to rising interest rates as they eat into the value of future cash flows.

Companies including Denmark’s Orsted, the world’s largest offshore wind farm developer, and U.S. panel maker First Solar have seen sharp share price falls in recent months.

“Renewable energy funds have faced weakened sentiment due to company performances in recent quarters and a shift in investor attention this year toward other themes like AI and U.S. Infrastructure,” said Global X research analyst Madeline Ruid.

Long-permitting timelines, project delays, high rates and elevated material costs – particularly for wind and solar power – have weighed on firms, Ms. Ruid said.

The iShares Global Clean Energy Exchange Traded Fund lost a net US$278.4-million in the last quarter, the data showed. Investors pulled a net US$218.3-million and US$199.1-million from the Hallbar Energi and iShares Global Clean Energy UCITS ETF USD (Dist), respectively.

Demand for exposure to renewable energy had been a major driver of cash flowing into climate-related funds in recent years.

However, “climate transition” funds – which invest in companies that want to decarbonize faster – and “climate solutions” funds are the biggest sectors “as investors look for investment opportunities beyond the renewable energy sector," data provider Morningstar said in a recent report.

The S&P Global Clean Energy Index, comprised of major solar and wind power companies and other renewables-related businesses, has lost 30 per cent in 2023, with nearly all of the decline since July.

By contrast, the oil and gas-heavy S&P 500 Energy Index is up slightly this year.

***************************************

My other blogs. Main ones below

http://dissectleft.blogspot.com (DISSECTING LEFTISM )

http://edwatch.blogspot.com (EDUCATION WATCH)

http://pcwatch.blogspot.com (POLITICAL CORRECTNESS WATCH)

http://australian-politics.blogspot.com (AUSTRALIAN POLITICS)

http://snorphty.blogspot.com/ (TONGUE-TIED)

http://jonjayray.com/blogall.html More blogs

*****************************************

Thursday, October 12, 2023


Another obsessional attack on a common herbicide

The article below occurs under the heading: "Two herbicides detected in up to 98% of children may cause learning and social difficulties, study warns".

The relevant journal article is: "Urinary Glyphosate, 2,4-D and DEET Biomarkers in Relation to Neurobehavioral Performance in Ecuadorian Adolescents in the ESPINA Cohort"

If a weed-killer could have horns and a tail it would be Roundup (glyphosate). It's a huge help to farmers but to Greenies it seems to be the devil incarnate. For years now, they have been obsessed with proving it's harmful to people. Anything so popular has to be bad, seems to be the thinking.

But all their efforts have revealed little. Mostly no harm is found and if it is obscure statistical gyrations have to be enlisted to make any sort of point. The latest study is a case in point.

It is difficult to know where to start unravelling the nonsense below so I will make just a few salient points. For a start it was a study of farm children in Ecuador. Ecuador? Would results from Ecuador be the same as resuts from the USA? Who knows? The possibilities for differences would seem to be many.

Secondly, they gave the kids a whole range of tests to examine what might be wrong with them. Only one, Affect Recognition, was significantly associated with glyphosate presence, and only weakly at that. The result drops to non-ignificance if an experiment-wise error rate approach had been adopted -- which is what should have happened when many candidate influences had been examined at the same time. So that's very thin gruel for the glyphosayte haters.

But wait! There's more, as the steak knife salesman used to say. Let me revert to my first point above: That the study was done in Ecuador. The validity of tests used cross-culturally is often low to non-existent so cannot be assumed. And no cross-cultural validation for the tests used seems to have been done for this study. One one occasion when I attempted a cross cultural validity test for one of my scales, the validity turned out to be zero! See https://jonjayray.tripod.com/collapse.html

But to enlist the steak-knife salesman once more, even that is not the end of it. In the test manual, the reliabilities given for Affect Recognition in the age groups concerned were in the .50 range. Which is below what is normally accepted as adequaate in a research instument

In short, these results were nothing more that a parade of meaningless numbers. If anything, they confirm that gyphosate cannot be shown as harmful



The two most widely used herbicides in the world may cause learning problems and poor memory and social skills in children, a study has warned.

Using urine samples and test performance scores from adolescents, researchers found that traces of glyphosate, the most heavily applied herbicide in the US, and common weed killer 24D, were linked to worse brain function.

Researchers from the University of California San Diego found that glyphosate was present in 98 percent of the 520 samples.

People may be exposed to the chemicals by eating contaminated food or drinking water, and it is thought the substances affect the pathways in the brain linked to memory and learning.

Other research has found that glyphosate is in up to 90 percent of wheat-based products such as pizza, crackers and pasta.

Over the last two decades, there has been a substantial rise in chronic diseases and mental health disorders in young adults worldwide.

'Exposure to neurotoxic contaminants in the environment could play a part of this increase,' said senior study author Dr Jose Ricardo Suarez, associate professor at UC San Diego.

The researchers measured the concentrations of two popular herbicides in urine samples: glyphosate and 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid, better known as 2,4D.

The urine samples were collected in 2016 from 519 children aged between 11 and 17 living in the agricultural county of Pedro Moncayo, Ecuador.

Herbicides are the most commonly used class of pesticides worldwide, often used to kill weeds.

Elevated PFAS levels linked to higher cancer, low birth weight rates

Cities with the highest levels of toxic 'forever chemicals' in tap water also have above-average rates of disease and pregnancy complications, a DailyMail.com analysis suggests.

Glyphosate, used in crops such as corn and soy, is a nonselective herbicide, meaning it kills all vegetation in an area rather than just weeds.

It was detected in 98 percent of participant samples.

2,4D, a herbicide used to kill leafy weeds, was detected in 66 percent of the urine samples.

The researchers also examined the adolescents' performance in five areas: attention and inhibitory control (how well you can stop impulses), memory and learning, language, spatial awareness, and social perception.

They did this by looking through the test scores from 2016 on things like how quickly the children could understand a set of instructions, how well they could remember faces and how quickly they could solve shape puzzles.

Higher amounts of 2,4D in urine were linked to worse scores in the tests for attention and inhibitory control, memory and learning, and language.

Glyphosate concentration in urine was only connected to lower scores in social perception.

The most common glyphosate product is Roundup weed killer, made by Monsanto.

There have been significant increases in glyphosate and 2,4D use following the introduction of genetically modified, glyphosate-resistant "Roundup-ready" crops in 1996 and 2,4D-resistant crops in 2014, the study authors said.

Bayer, the owner of the chemical manufacturing company, has long maintained that exposure to the weed killer has no negative impacts on human health.

The study was published Wednesday in the journal Environmental Health Perspectives.

***********************************************************

Antrctica not blossoming after all

A Sept. 21 Instagram post shows flowering plants growing on land with icebergs floating on water in the background.

"Flowers are now staring (sic) to bloom in Antarctica and experts say this is not good news," reads text around the image. "This would be the first evidence of accelerated ecosystem response in Antarctica that is directly associated as a consequence of global warming, according to Nicoletta Cannone, a professor of ecology at the University of Insubria."

While a 2022 study did find a global warming-related expansion in the range of two Antarctic flowering plants, the photo does not show those plant species. The photo is labeled as being captured in Greenland on a stock photo website.

The photo in the social media post appears on the stock photo website Alamy, where it is labeled, "Iceberg floating in the water off the coast of Greenland. Flowers on the shore. Nature and landscapes of Greenland."

A spokesperson for the British Antarctic Survey told USA TODAY the photo "most definitely does not show Antarctic plants."

"The purple flower looks very much like Saxifraga oppositifolia − Purple saxifrage − which is frequent in the Arctic," the spokesperson said.

Skip Walker, director of the Alaska Geobotany Center, also told USA TODAY the plants in the photo are likely from the Arctic. "I can't identify the plants with certainty, but they all look like Arctic plants," he said in an email.

Matt Davey, an ecologist at the Scottish Association for Marine Science, told USA TODAY there are only two species of flowering plants in Antarctica: Colobanthus quitensis and Deschampsia antarctica.

"The flowers in (the) photo are definitely not the two Antarctic flowering plants," he said in an email.

The text associated with the image seems to loosely quote a 2022 paper co-authored by Nicoletta Cannone, an ecology professor at the University of Insubria in Italy.

************************************************

Thanks, New York Times, For Finally Admitting Honey Bees Are Doing Great

Greenies have been moaning for years about declining bee populations

A recent New York Times (NYT) article titled “The Beekeepers Who Don’t Want You to Buy More Bees,” explains that contrary to popular media narratives, honey bee populations are healthy and numerous. This is true. Colony collapse disorder, the main threat to bees, is largely a commercial bee problem and not necessarily a wild honey bee problem.

In the article, professional bee-keeper Gorazd Trusnovec explains to NYT writer David Segal that the well-intentioned growing popularity of beekeeping is actually misguided, because there are now actually too many honey bees in areas all around the world.

“If you overcrowd any space with honey bees, there is a competition for natural resources, and since bees have the largest numbers, they push out other pollinators, which actually harms biodiversity,” he said, after a recent visit to the B&B bees. “I would say that the best thing you could do for honey bees right now is not take up beekeeping.”

Segal goes on to describe colony collapse disorder, which is a phenomena seen in commercial beekeeping in which a large portion of a bee hive or colony dies or is wiped out. Segal writes that “experts tend to blame pesticides, an invasive parasite, a reduction in forageable habitat and climate change,” and this tracks with what Climate Realism has seen and combatted previously.

However, climate change is not among the best explanations for the problem, as explained in “Tell the Truth, UPI News, Parasites and Pesticides, NOT Climate Change, Are Killing Honey Bee Colonies,” or in the June Climate Fact Check.
Extreme weather like heat waves and precipitation aren’t occurring more frequently as measured by any metric, so climate change can’t be implicated in increasing numbers of commercial bee hives being damaged across large geographic regions.

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency lists the factors it believes are the most likely causes of the decline in bees and other pollinators:

The alarm around colony collapse disorder (CCD) caused a huge spike in interest in beekeeping in order to “save the bees,” however as a another professional conservationist interviewed by Segal explained, CCD is “an agriculture story, not a conservation story[.]” In fact, there are “more honey bees on the planet than there have ever been in human history.” Segal writes that the number of hives in the world has risen 26 percent in just the last 10 years.

The New York Times itself has contributed to spreading fallacious claims about climate change and CCD, like in “Without Bees, We Are in Trouble,” and for bumblebees, “Climate Change: It’s a Buzzkill for Bumblebees, Study Finds,” in the past, so the present story is refreshing for its accuracy.

Beekeeping has become so popular in places like Slovenia, for example, that the NYT reports honey yields are dropping locally despite a huge increase in hives because there is not enough plant nectar for all the bees.

Honey bees are also not the only pollinators around, and an overabundance of them could negatively impact the populations of other bee species, like bumblebees, as well as non-bee pollinators. This is particularly true in places like North America, where honey bees are an introduced species brought over by European settlers as livestock for honey production. They are not native here, and are considered by conservationists to be invasive competitors to native species.

Honey bees are doing more than fine, regardless of climate change. According to this NYT investigation, they are almost doing too well, due to an increase in the number of beekeepers. Commercial beehives experiencing CCD are not indicative of the health of the entire species, and certainly climate change is not to blame for their problems. Thanks, NYT, for looking beyond the narrative that “climate change causes everything,” to get to the true root cause of the struggles of honey bees and other pollinators, at least in this one story.

*********************************************************

'I was kidnapped by my runaway electric car'

A driver has told how he was "kidnapped" by his runaway electric car and forced to dodge red lights and roundabouts.

Brian Morrison, 53, from Glasgow, said he was heading home from work on Sunday night when he said his brand new MG ZS EV became stuck at 30mph.

Police were forced to stop the runaway car by allowing it to slowly crash into their police van.

MG Motor UK said it was trying to resolve the matter.

A spokesman said: "MG Motor UK has been urgently trying to make contact with Mr Morrison so that his vehicle can be fully inspected by our engineering team.

"We take this matter very seriously and now that contact has been made, we are making every effort to resolve matters quickly and comprehensively for him."

Police Scotland confirmed it had responded to "a driver unable to stop his electric car".

Mr Morrison said his car suffered a ''catastrophic malfunction'' and became stuck at 30mph on the A803 heading towards Kirkintilloch, near Glasgow.

He said he was lucky that the incident had taken place after 22:00 on a Sunday night when the roads were quiet.

"I realised something was wrong when I was coming up to a roundabout and went to slow down but it didn't do it," he said.

"Then I heard a loud grinding noise that sounded like brake pads, but because it was such a new car I knew it couldn't be a problem with them.

"I managed to get around the roundabout going at about 30mph and then had a long road ahead of me, so I assumed it would stop without me accelerating - but it didn't."

Mr Morrison has mobility issues, so he was unable to escape the car travelling at 30mph by jumping out.

He added: "It might not sound like it is very fast, but when you have no control over the speed and you're completely stuck inside, it's terrifying."

Mr Morrison initially called his wife in a panic to ask her to warn vehicles ahead of him that he could not stop his car.

He called 999 when he grew concerned about crashing into pedestrians and navigating more roundabouts and traffic lights.

"The car was just running away on its own, there was nothing I could do," he said.

"When I dialled 999, they sent police to help and put some engineers on the line to try and solve the problem, and they were asking if it was a self-driving car.

"It was the first time that the call handlers had experienced the issue, and they had no idea what to do."

Soon after he made the call, three police vehicles arrived and drove in front and behind the car.

He said: "I was 100% concentrating on my steering, so when a police van pulled up besides me and asked if I was Brian and if I was okay, I just yelled 'no I'm not, I can't stop'."

Police asked Mr Morrison to throw his electronic key through their van window before driving off, and then tried forcibly shutting off the engine - but nothing could stop the car.

He was also asked to hold the power button for a couple of seconds which also failed to stop it and the entire dashboard lit up with faults.

Officers decided to get him to crash into the back of their van before he got into a more built-up area.

Mr Morrison said: "Eventually I came up to a roundabout which slowed the car down to about 15mph and the police van was waiting for me on the other side.

"I went into the back of the van while it was moving, before they put on the brakes to stop me.

''After that, a police officer jumped into my car and did something which seemed to keep the car still."

The police could not move their car as the electric vehicle would keep moving, so they had to wait for the RAC to arrive.

"I still have no idea what happened," he said. "But when the RAC got to me about three hours later, he plugged in the car to do a diagnostic check and there was pages of faults.

"He said he had never seen anything like it and decided he was not willing to turn the engine on to see what was wrong."

Mr Morrison's insurance said they were investigating the incident, which has left him unsure if he would drive another electric vehicle again.

***************************************

My other blogs. Main ones below

http://dissectleft.blogspot.com (DISSECTING LEFTISM )

http://edwatch.blogspot.com (EDUCATION WATCH)

http://pcwatch.blogspot.com (POLITICAL CORRECTNESS WATCH)

http://australian-politics.blogspot.com (AUSTRALIAN POLITICS)

http://snorphty.blogspot.com/ (TONGUE-TIED)

http://jonjayray.com/blogall.html More blogs

*****************************************

Wednesday, October 11, 2023



Wrong, CNBC and U.S. Treasury Department, Climate Change Is Unlikely to Impose New Costs on Households

An article published by CNBC cites a recent report by the U.S. Treasury Department to claim that climate change is likely to impose “substantial financial costs” on U.S. households in the coming years and decades. This is misinformation. The costs estimates are based on computer models and emission scenarios that are known to be flawed and data on extreme weather trends do not show they are worsening. As a result, there is no evidence climate change has at the present or will in the future resulting in higher household costs.

Annie Nova’s CNBC article, “Climate change could impose ‘substantial financial costs’ on U.S. household finances, Treasury warns,” reports on a new report from the U.S. Treasury Department which claims that climate change will likely result in rising prices, and supply chain and job disruptions due to “climate disasters” resulting from a warming planet. Nova writes:

Climate change is expected to impose “substantial financial costs” on U.S. households in the coming years, according to a new report by the U.S. Department of the Treasury.

Between 2018 and 2022, weather and climate disasters cost more than $617 billion, it found — a record. Within the last year, 13% of Americans reported economic hardship due to severe weather events and disasters.

“Severe flooding, wildfires and extreme heat are imposing significant financial burdens on households across the country,” Graham Steele, assistant secretary for financial institutions at the Treasury Department, said in a statement.

The first thing to note about the Treasury Department’s report is that, although the data set it used did adjust for inflation, it did not adjust for Gross Domestic Product (GDP). As Climate Realism has discussed previously, here and here, for example, data shows that when GDP growth is accounted for, losses to extreme weather events have declined during the recent period of modest warming.

In addition, the data set it used was truncated, only extending back to 1980. This is important because data shows that hurricanes, wildfires, heatwaves, and droughts, for example, were more numerous, powerful, and impacted larger areas of land in the middle and early part of the 20th century than at present. Yet Treasury’s report fails to compare the economic impact on households of events occurring in these earlier time periods, when weather was more severe, with the present time period. Of course, there were fewer people and less development then, but that would likely make the gap between the GDP adjusted economic impacts even larger than they are now.

In addition, as discussed at Climate at a Glance: Hurricane’s, from 2005 through 2017, the year before the cost data cited by the Treasury Department and CNBC spiked, the United States went through the longest period in history without a major hurricane—a hurricane measuring Category 3 or higher—making landfall. The United States also experienced the fewest number of hurricane strikes in any eight year period in recorded history (2009 through 2017). So the Treasury Department staked its claims of huge increases in losses on a comparison between a period of relatively high hurricane activity with the period of the lowest hurricane activity in history. As a result, it is no wonder Treasury’s cost data seems to have risen dramatically. With that cheery picking of time periods for comparison, how could it not do so?

Then there is the use of computer models to project future rising consumer costs and wage losses. As Climate Realism has discussed repeatedly, here, here, and here for, for example, computer models grossly overstate the amount of warming experienced and the weather impacts of that warming, so damage cost estimate based on such models can’t be relied upon—it’s garbage in, garbage out. In addition, impact projections rely on extremely unlikely or even impossible emission scenarios.

What the data clearly shows as discussed in dozens of previous Climate Realism posts, none of the trends for extreme weather events, droughts, floods, heat waves, hurricanes, or wildfires, are rising. Indeed, most have declined over the period of recent modest warming, so climate change can’t be causing the recent increase in disaster related impacts.

The recent rise in costs is due to a few years of bad weather—by the way, its not unusual historically for years of bad weather to run in short streaks due to the effect that large scale cycles like El Nino and La Nina events have on atmospheric trends—and increasing numbers of people moving to places historically prone to natural disasters and building more, and more expensive, properties there. As explored in Climate Realism previously, here, for instance, rising nominal costs from hurricane damage, and the damage from other natural disasters, are due to what Bjorn Lomborg, Ph.D., calls the “expanding bulls-eye effect.”

The Biden administration is deeply committed to combatting climate change, which Biden has asserted, without real evidence by the way, “is a real and present danger.” The Treasury Department is a federal agency in the Biden administration. So it is hardly surprising the Treasury Department would issues an alarming climate report that is short on facts, but long on scary scenarios and supposition. By contrast, the Federal Reserve, an agency independent of the administration has issued repeated reports and statements making it clear that climate change is not increasing banks costs nor does it threaten their continued ability to operate.

Sadly, in its reporting, CNBC ignored the facts, instead choosing to unquestioningly parrot the U.S. Treasury Department’s flawed claims. So much for investigative, independent, journalism.

***********************************************

Germany brings back mothballed coal plants to keep the lights on

A country on the forefront of the green transition will put several mothballed coal-fired power plants back online ahead of the upcoming winter, Bloomberg News reported Wednesday.

Germany, which has spent hundreds of billions of dollars to enact the green energy transition, will reactivate several coal-fired units in order to meet peak demand and keep the lights on this winter, Bloomberg reported. The country has experienced elevated and inconsistent energy prices since Russia invaded Ukraine, impacting both German customers and companies.

The German government opted to go ahead with its plans to phase out its last nuclear reactors in April, and the war in Ukraine has resulted in diminished flow of relatively inexpensive natural gas from Russia, according to Bloomberg. German officials have cited safety concerns and a desire to focus on developing green energy as their rationale for shuttering the remaining reactors.

The country needed to rely on coal last winter once the flow of Russian gas had slowed, and supply is likely to be even tighter this winter now that the nuclear reactors are out of the picture, Bloomberg reported.

The energy crisis and inconsistencies in the power market have contributed to the decisions of many companies to scale down their operations in Germany and look for more stable, affordable business environments in North America and Asia, according to Politico.

The decision for this winter affects two coal blocks from RWE’s Niederaußem plant — blocks E and F — as well as the Neurath plant’s block C. In the east of the country, LEAG is expected to bring blocks E and F of its Jaenschwalde lignite plant back online. The facilities were operational last winter, put on stand-by in July, and can now be fully reactivated until March 2024 the latest.

**********************************************

Climate scientists admit they have a 90% chance of being wrong about Arctic sea ice

Arctic sea ice is lowest during the month of September, and its average extent during this month is a useful metric for measuring Arctic sea ice decline during the current period of global warming. During the 1980s and 1990s, September Arctic sea-ice extent (SIE) showed a moderate decline (Figure 1). After the 1997 climate shift, which involved a rather abrupt global atmospheric reorganization, the Arctic entered a period of rapid change that I call the Arctic Shift.

During this period, Arctic SIE declined more rapidly. Scientists noticed this change in trend about a decade later and became increasingly concerned about the prospect of an ice-free Arctic.[2]

The concern about the rapid decline of Arctic SIE in the early years of this century was due to the possibility of a runaway ice-albedo feedback. Loss of sea ice would reduce albedo, and additional solar energy would cause further sea ice loss. Models that reproduced the rapid loss predicted a tipping point that would lead to an ice-free Arctic by 2040, sparking public fears. [3]

However, recent work suggests that up to 60% of the decline in September SIE since 1979 may be due to changes in atmospheric circulation. [4] In addition, the persistence of Arctic summer cloud cover significantly reduces the ice-albedo feedback.[5] The realization that internal variability is a more important factor than expected explains why the rate of decline of Arctic summer SIE has slowed so much since 2007, contrary to all expectations.

The Arctic Shift, a period of adjustment of Arctic climate variables to the new atmospheric regime induced by the 1997 climate shift, ended for Arctic SIE in 2007. Since then, the September Arctic SIE shows no significant trend. However, climate researchers are still unaware of the effects of climate shifts and regimes on climate change, and they were surprised by the recovery of sea ice in 2013 when it became clear that there had been no net loss since 2007. Using models, they calculated a 34% chance of a 7-year pause (Figure 2).[6]

However, the hiatus has now extended to 17 years and the probability has dropped to 10%. In other words, there is a 90% chance that climate scientists’ predictions about Arctic sea ice were wrong. If the hiatus continues until 2027, it will become statistically significant (p<0.05, or less than 5%) and no longer explainable by chance.

***********************************************

Right, Fox News, Renewable Energy Subsidies Dominate Federal Energy Handouts

Fox News posted an article that analyzes a recent Energy Information Administration (EIA) report which shows that renewable energy subsidies dominate federal energy handouts. This is contrary to claims commonly made by activists and mainstream media sources that green energy is cheaper than traditional sources, and that fossil fuels receive massive federal subsidies.

The Fox News article, “Biden admin quietly released study showing green energy receives far more subsidies than fossil fuels,” performs a basic review of the 59-page report from the Department of Energy’s EIA, and concludes that fossil fuels and nuclear energy receive a pittance of federal backing compared to green energy and energy efficiency programs.

Breaking down the Fox analysis:

From 2016 to 2022, the federal government awarded $183.3 billion in direct and indirect subsidies. More than half was spent in the last three years.

Although renewables like wind and solar account for only 21% of domestic electricity production, they received the largest share of subsidies at $83.8 billion, approximately 46 percent of all subsidies.

Fox reports the next largest category are “[e]nergy end use subsidies, like energy efficiency- and conservation-related tax provisions,” receiving $64.8 billion, meaning consumers, homeowners, and commercial and retail businesses get approximately 35 percent of the subsidies, in the form of write downs on their tax bills.

Fossil fuel sources, which make up more than 60% of electricity production and most transportation energy, got only $24.5 billion, approximately 13 percent of the subsidies, all most all in the form of tax credits for routine business expenses, the kind of credits every other business and industry in America receives.

Nuclear power, alone producing 18% of our electricity, only got $2.9 billion.

Fox writer Thomas Catenacci also discussed what these values mean in terms of how much taxpayer money is being spent per unit of energy produced by renewables versus traditional energy sources, and predictably found that “green” sources are far more costly.

Catenacci writes:

For example, natural gas power generated 44.9 quadrillion British thermal units in 2022, 45% of total energy generated economywide, but received $2.3 billion in taxpayer subsidies that year. That means for every million British thermal units (MMBtu) produced by natural gas, the industry received about $0.05.

By comparison, in 2022, the solar industry generated about 0.6 quadrillion British thermal units, less than 1% of total energy produced economywide in the U.S., but received $7.5 billion in subsidies. That means the solar power industry received $11.9 per MMBtu generated last year.

To those who follow energy issues closely, this should be no surprise.

While the Biden administration and likeminded mainstream media outlets and activists champion ideas like eliminating tax advantages for traditional sources, especially fossil fuels, the reality has always been that these sources already receive very little government help compared to wind and solar, in particular. The reality also is that these supposed “tax advantages” are tax credits common to every industry and business for capital expenditures, equipment, employee benefits, etc. They are not unique, “give aways,” to the fossil fuel industry.

It should be noted that the EIA report emphasizes the fact that its scope is “limited to direct federal financial interventions and subsidies,” This is notable, because individual state renewable portfolio standards and interstate programs like the northeast’s Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative also add to these subsidies, in part by mandating the increased use of “green” energy. One study found that the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative cost electricity ratepayers $3.8 billion extra between 2008 to 2020, and more than half of those funds went to energy efficiency programs. In addition, it does not include tax abatements and support given directly to green energy developments by state and local governments.

Solar receives by far the largest share of the federal subsidies in the form of tax expenditures, according to the EIA report and the chart they generated. (See figure below)

Solar alone receives more subsidies in the form of tax expenditures than all energy specific subsidies and support for any given traditional energy source. The EIA report explains this by saying that the industry has grown rapidly, and because the investment tax credit is claimed in full the year an asset enters commercial operation.

Solar power is proving itself to be much less reliable than proponents claim, as discussed in a Climate Realism post, “Two New Reports Detail the Unreliability of Solar Power.” One report found that solar assets were degrading at roughly double the rate the industry claims. The same is true for other renewables, even in states that supply large amounts of support for their development.

Despite the subsidies, states with renewable portfolio standards have seen increases in retail electricity prices.

As amusing as it is that renewables receive so much more “subsidies” in the form of tax expenditures, tax breaks are probably not what most Americans think of when they imagine companies receiving subsidies. That simply means that money is not taken away from the companies by government. But the EIA report also discusses direct expenditures – or money from taxpayers given to companies directly in the form of grants and programs. Examining this data shows that renewables receive the bulk of this funding as well. (See figure below)

Direct expenditures make up only 10 percent of all the subsidies and support natural gas and petroleum liquids receive, and come out negative for coal due to “de-obligation of funds” related to carbon capture and storage and the Clean Coal Power Initiative (two green projects).

The EIA report says the two billion-dollar years for renewables’ direct expenditures came primarily from two sources; Congress created direct-payment programs at the Treasury that renewables companies could opt for instead of tax credits from the Production Tax Credit for renewable electricity generation, as well as the Clean Renewable Energy Bonds and Qualified Energy Conservation Bond programs.

It is also important to note that the direct expenditures for “natural gas and petroleum liquids” does not merely include funding for oilfield operations. The vast majority of the direct expenditures go to U.S. Department of Transportation related projects, like pipeline safety programs, mandated by the government, and U.S. EPA programs like the clean diesel emissions reduction program, and state clean diesel grant program. Because those programs have little to do with the kind of “big oil payouts” the media claims exist, we did not include them in our numbers. What little direct upstream payments do exist are dominated by the Department of the Interior’s “Oil and Gas Royalty Management State and Tribal Coordination” – which covers the federal disbursements given to tribes every year for energy production on their land.

The EIA also separately breaks down where Research and Development (R&D) grants go. Renewables have received a total of $2.364 billion in R&D since 2016, coal got $2.383 billion (the vast majority going towards carbon capture and storage and other “net zero” projects), gas and petroleum liquids saw just $739 million, and nuclear got $1.684 billion.

In fact, among the direct payments, whether by direct expenditure or R&D grants, most money for any given energy source is going towards some form of “green” or net-zero application of the energy source.

The jury is still out on whether or not the mainstream media and Biden administration will stop falsely claiming that fossil fuels receive “significant tax preferences and subsidies,” as stated in the tax plan released in 2021. The EIA report was released in August, and since then, there has not been a peep from the administration.

Fox News did a great job publicizing the facts contained in this EIA report, about the relative amounts of subsidies going to different energy sources compared relative to the amount of power they provide to the American economy and people. It’s a shame other mainstream media outlets ignored the EIA’s findings. Had they discussed it, average Americans would have been more energy literate and able to make better informed choices at the ballot box. The media often claims that part of its job is to produce a well-informed citizenry, not one making personal and political decisions based on misinformation. On energy, it is failing grossly in that job.

**************************************************

Soil carbon and its magic credits another offset industry fantasy

Australia’s carbon credit system has a new and rapidly growing source of flawed Australian carbon credit units (ACCUs). The “soil carbon” industry is small in scale, but it features the same problems as the increasingly discredited human-induced regeneration (HIR) industry which has produced tens of millions of carbon credits for carbon sequestration that there’s no evidence has taken place.

Soil carbon refers to increasing the storage of carbon in the soil, usually via increasing crop or pasture yields, and keeping the amount of carbon released from soil via decomposition to a minimum. Almost 480 soil carbon projects have been accredited under the government’s ACCU scheme, nearly two-thirds of which have commenced in the past two years, so the industry is in relative infancy, with only a few hundred thousand ACCUs issued.

But from later this decade, it will begin producing millions of ACCUs to be used as offset by heavy CO2 polluters continuing business-as-usual emissions.

A who’s who of Australian primary industries scientists recently outlined four critical failings of the current soil carbon methodology used by the Clean Energy Regulator.

Like HIR projects, changes in soil carbon levels are more likely to reflect external factors such as rainfall or drought than human interventions, which are the basis of crediting ACCUs. And when soil carbon levels fall due to drought or fire, for example, as with HIR projects, there is no requirement to hand back the generated ACCUs — unlike the emissions the ACCUs “offset”, which will remain in the atmosphere for thousands of years. The only recognition of soil carbon variability is a temporary 25% buffer that initially — but not permanently — reduces the number of ACCUs issued.
But in some ways, soil carbon is even riskier as a form of sequestration than HIR.

Independent measurement of soil carbon levels is far harder than assessing HIR, with project proponents able to pick the best samples from within projects to maximise results without detection, compared with satellite imagery that can identify tree regeneration for HIR projects. And assessment of soil carbon levels isn’t merely dependent on place but on time — projects commenced during drought will naturally record a significant increase in soil carbon levels after the end of drought and subsequent increases in rainfall.

As a long roster of scientists pointed out recently, some soil carbon projects have recorded increases in soil carbon far beyond those suggested as credible in scientific literature, including at unlikely soil depths. As the scientists note, the key problem is transparency, or its lack — just as with HIR.

“Scientists should be granted access to project data. Data could be used to improve models in order to distinguish between climate and management effects. This would ensure the method is fit for purpose,” they conclude.

As with HIR, however, there is minimal access to project data (the “voluntary” additional data provided by HIR proponents in response to criticism of those projects is nearly worthless) and efforts to provide rigorous independent verification meet with hostility from the Clean Energy Regulator and the industry.

The dismissal of strong evidence of the lack of integrity of HIR projects, and the lack of interest in identified and significant flaws in the soil carbon methodology suggests that the goal of the Clean Energy Regulator — acting under direction from successive governments — is less about the quality of ACCUs than the quantity, that the priority is producing a high volume of credits with a pretence of rigour that will be available to heavy emitters to continue polluting.

***************************************

My other blogs. Main ones below

http://dissectleft.blogspot.com (DISSECTING LEFTISM )

http://edwatch.blogspot.com (EDUCATION WATCH)

http://pcwatch.blogspot.com (POLITICAL CORRECTNESS WATCH)

http://australian-politics.blogspot.com (AUSTRALIAN POLITICS)

http://snorphty.blogspot.com/ (TONGUE-TIED)

http://jonjayray.com/blogall.html More blogs

*****************************************

Tuesday, October 10, 2023



Terrifying heat maps reveal the countries that will become too HOT to live in if global temperatures increase by just 1.5°C

What arrant nonsense! Amid the large daily temperature variations common in many parts of the world, an increase of 1.5 degrees would hardly be noticed.

I grew up in tropical Australia (FNQ) where a 38 degree Celsius (100F) daytime temperature was not uncommon. And it was usually humid too. We coped perfectly well. And we mostly had fair skin, blue eyes and spoke English. But we drank a lot of cold beer.

But I will concede that a degree of acclimatization may be needed to live comfortably in FNQ. Two generations of my family before me had CHOSEN to live in that area

The mistake made by the authors below may be thinking that residents of the Northern USA are typical of the human race


These frightening heat maps reveal the countries that could soon become too hot to live in if global temperatures increase by as little as 1.5°C (2.7°F).

Some 2.2 billion people in Pakistan and India's Indus River Valley, 1 billion in eastern China and 800 million in sub-Saharan Africa would be among those facing heat that is beyond human tolerance, researchers say.

That could extend to eastern and central parts of the US if temperatures on Earth were to rise by 3°C (5.4°F) above pre-industrial levels.

Residents in Florida, New York, Houston and Chicago would all have to endure dangerous and stifling levels of humidity, while extreme heat could wreak havoc among those living in parts of South America and Australia, according to the new study by Penn State University.

Humans can only endure so much heat before putting themselves at risk of a heart attack or heat stroke.

Record-breaking heatwaves across the US, Europe and China this summer once again threw the spotlight on just how much heat is too much for people.

Last year, researchers from Penn State revealed how the upper temperature limit for human safety was much lower than first thought.

Previously it had been thought that a wet-bulb temperature of 95°F (35°C) – equal to a temperature of 95°F at 100 per cent humidity, or 115°F at 50 per cent humidity – was the upper limit.

At this point the human body would no longer be able to cool itself by evaporating sweat from the surface of the body to ensure a stable body core temperature.

However, the latest research suggests the upper limit is actually 87°F (31°C) at 100 per cent humidity or 100°F (38°C) at 60 per cent humidity.

The key point to note is that it is not just about what the thermometer says. Instead, it is the combination of heat and humidity - known as the 'wet-bulb temperature'.

This is a direct indicator of how well sweating is cooling the body and is measured by attaching a wet cloth to the bulb of a thermometer.

In human history, temperatures and humidity that exceed human limits have been recorded only a handful of times — and only for a few hours.

In parts of India, Pakistan, eastern China and sub-Saharan Africa, residents would have to endure high-humidity heatwaves if global warming is not curbed.

These can be particularly dangerous because it means the air cannot absorb excess moisture, which in turn limits the amount of sweat that evaporates from the human body.

What is particularly worrying, the researchers said, is that many of the areas that would be worst affected are in lower-to-middle income nations who likely wouldn't have access to air conditioning.

In the worst-case scenario of global temperatures rising by 4°C (7.2°F), the port city of Al Hudaydah in Yemen – which is home to more than 700,000 people on the Red Sea – would be almost uninhabitable.

That is because residents would have to endure temperatures exceeding the limits of human tolerance on 300 days of the year.

'The worst heat stress will occur in regions that are not wealthy and that are expected to experience rapid population growth in the coming decades,' said co-author Matthew Huber, of Purdue University.

'But this research shows that humid heat is going to be a much bigger threat than dry heat.

The new study has been published in the journal Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

*****************************************************

That pesky ozone hole refuses to shrink

The Greenies thought they knew how to close it but their methods have not worked. The hole has never co-operated. It just fluctuates in its own sweet way regardless

A hole in the ozone layer three times larger than Brazil has opened up over Antarctica.

Europe’s Copernicus Sentinel-5P satellite shows that the ozone hole is one of the largest on record, according to the European Space Agency (ESA), and measured 26mn square kilometres on September 16, 2023 – roughly three times the size of Brazil.

Satellite data revealed that this year's ozone hole expanded to about twice the size of Antarctica. The eruption of Tonga's underwater volcano in early 2022 is a possible cause for the unusual size of the ozone hole, say scientists.

The ozone layer in Earth's atmosphere is approximately 15 to 30 kilometres above the surface and protects the planet from harmful ultraviolet rays from the sun. Ozone is a type of oxygen molecule with three atoms instead of the usual two that absorbs the sun's radiation.

The discovery of significant ozone holes above Earth's polar regions was made in 1985. Researchers found that chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs), a common chemical used in aerosol cans, packaging materials and refrigerators at the time, were reacting with ozone in the atmosphere, leading to ozone depletion. In response, the international community banned the use of CFCs in 1989, allowing ozone levels to gradually recover.

However, gaps in the ozone layer still appear above the polar regions during each hemisphere's winter months. This occurs when cold air creates polar stratospheric clouds (PSCs), which are exceptionally high clouds composed of tiny ice cr

*************************************************

In blow to Germany's green agenda, conservatives and right-wing populists win regional elections

After key regional elections on Sunday in Germany conservatives and right-wing populists are celebrating.

But the results are a blow for all three parties in Chancellor Olaf Scholz's left-wing-led national coalition. The ramifications will be felt across Germany.

A quarter of voters were able to go to the polls in regional elections in two of Germany's largest and wealthiest states, Bavaria and Hesse.

In both regions, conservative and right-wing populist parties used the election campaign to bash Olaf Scholz's national government over migration and energy policy. It paid off.

In Hesse, according to initial predictions, the conservative incumbent CDU scored 34.5% of the vote, a substantial gain on its solid win last time.

The far-right AfD also upped its previous score by a couple of percent to a predicted 18%, which would be the AfD's highest score in a western German state election and put the party in second place.

All three parties in Scholz's national coalition have slipped a couple of percentage points, with both the Greens and Olaf Scholz's centre-left SPD at around 15%, and the free-market liberal FDP hovering at 4.9% and may miss the 5% threshold to stay in parliament.

In Bavaria the incumbent conservative CSU, who has led the regional government almost continually since 1946, won the most votes. Although with only 36.7%, according to predicted results, it's the party's worst result since 1958.

The CSU looks set to stay in power, but will need to stay in coalition with the right-wing populist Freie Wähler (Free Voters). Having scored their best result yet, at a predicted 15%, the insurgent Free Voters will feel emboldened and are already demanding another ministry.

************************************************

IPCC Global Warming Reports Underestimated Role of Sun in Warming: Study

Reports on global warming issued by the United Nations’ Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) underestimate the role of the Sun in the warming process while falsely laying blame on human beings, according to a study published last month.

In 2021, Ronan Connolly, a scientist at the Center for Environmental Research and Earth Science (CERES), and his colleagues published a review raising concerns about multiple reports issued by the IPCC. The IPCC reports concluded that global warming since the mid-20th century was essentially human-driven, dismissing natural causes behind the process. The 2021 review was disputed in a 2022 article by two climate researchers who claimed that the review was “flawed,” that it “should not be treated as credible,” and that the IPCC’s decision to rule out solar activity as a major driver behind climate change “remains intact.”

In a Sept. 27 study published in IOP Science, a team of 20 climate researchers led by Mr. Connolly sought to debunk the 2022 article and reaffirm the 2021 review. It found that the IPCC may have “substantially underestimated the role of the Sun in global warming,” according to a recent post by CERES.

The 2021 review noted that the IPCC reports had two major flaws:

For their analysis, the IPCC reports used global surface temperature data that was “contaminated by urban warming biases,” meaning that only temperature records from urban regions were considered. Urban areas tend to be warmer than the countryside due to human activity and various structures. Though urban areas only represent a small percentage of land, these places make up the majority of thermometer records used in estimating global temperatures.

The IPCC reports used only a small data set from a large pool of data related to Total Solar Irradiance (TSI), which measures the radiant energy emitted by the sun falling on Earth’s atmosphere. And this small data set used by IPCC mostly came to two conclusions—there have been very few TSI changes over the past centuries or that TSI has slightly decreased since the 1950s.

By analyzing data showing a rise in temperatures in urban regions and little to no change in Total Solar Irradiance, the IPCC reports blamed human activity for global warming, dismissing the sun’s role in the process.

In the 2022 article, the two climate researchers criticized the 2021 review, noting the following:

The mathematical techniques used in the review were inappropriate, and a different set of techniques should have been used.

The TSI records considered in the review were not up-to-date.
In the Sept. 27 study, Mr. Connolly and his team addressed these issues, finding “even more compelling evidence that the IPCC’s statements on the causes of global warming since 1850 are scientifically premature and may need to be revisited,” said the CERES post.

The Study

In the 2022 article, the climate researchers used just a single surface temperature record, which only contained data from urban regions. Meanwhile, the IPCC’s recent 2021 global warming report only considered one Total Solar Irradiance (TSI) data set in their calculations.

The Sept. 27 study took a more comprehensive approach and avoided these limitations of the IPCC’s 2021 report and the climate researchers’ 2022 article:

It used five surface temperature records—(a) only rural weather stations, (b) all available stations whether urban or rural, (c) only sea surface temperatures, (d) tree-ring widths as temperature proxies, and (e) glacier length records as temperature proxies.

It also used 27 updated TSI records, all covering the period between 1850 and 2018.

The study found that depending on the Total Solar Irradiance (TSI) dataset and surface temperature records used in the study, the conclusion as to what is driving global warming can change.

Some combinations of TSI and surface temperature records suggested that warming can be explained as being “mostly natural,” like solar activity. Other combinations suggested it was “mostly anthropogenic,” or human-driven. Some suggested warming was “both natural and anthropogenic.”

“While each of us has our own scientific opinions on which of these choices are most realistic, we are concerned by the wide range of scientifically plausible, yet mutually contradictory, conclusions that can still be drawn from the data,” the study said.

Talking about the results, Dr. Willie Soon, an author of the study, said that “if the IPCC had paid more attention to open-minded scientific inquiry than trying to force a premature ‘scientific consensus,’ then the scientific community would be a lot closer to having genuinely resolved the causes of climate change,” according to the CERES post.

Mr. Connolly highlighted the importance of remaining unbiased when conducting research. “In scientific investigations, it is important to avoid beginning your analysis with your conclusions decided in advance. Otherwise, you might end up with a false sense of confidence in your findings. It seems that the IPCC was too quick to jump to their conclusions.”

***************************************

My other blogs. Main ones below

http://dissectleft.blogspot.com (DISSECTING LEFTISM )

http://edwatch.blogspot.com (EDUCATION WATCH)

http://pcwatch.blogspot.com (POLITICAL CORRECTNESS WATCH)

http://australian-politics.blogspot.com (AUSTRALIAN POLITICS)

http://snorphty.blogspot.com/ (TONGUE-TIED)

http://jonjayray.com/blogall.html More blogs

*****************************************

Monday, October 09, 2023



More Greenie authoritarianism

Climate change activists are calling for airlines to introduce flight quotas, with travellers to instead commute long distances using ground transport.

Dr Helen Hutchinson, social scientist and spokesperson for environmental group Flight Free Australia, believes flying should be scrapped entirely until it's 'safe' or emission-free.

'It's an individual action – it's the worst thing you can do,' Dr Hutchinson told 3AW's Tom Elliott on Thursday.

'A lot of that's due to the fact we've prioritised air [travel]. A lot of other countries have actually put an equal amount of money into ground transport - such as really good buses, really good trains - and we could've done the same in Australia.'

'When you look at what's happening in Australia now, most of our long-distance trains have been privatised,' she continued.

Elliott then questioned the activist on time constraints, explaining he gets a 'week off at this time of year' in which he spent six days in Queensland with his family.

'Now, if we'd driven it's a two-day drive there and a two-day drive back which only leaves two days to enjoy it. It's just not possible,' he argued.

'Well, there's places in the world now where they're asking employers to give people time to get to the destination. And you can go [to Queensland] by train,' Dr Hutchinson said.

The host then cuts Dr Hutchinson off, remarking that it still takes two days to get to Queensland by train to which the activist simply responds: 'Yep, I've just done it.'

'What I'm suggesting is maybe you can ask for an extra four days which you can travel there and travel back,' she added.

Modern day Australia couldn't exist without flying, Elliott responded.

'The Melbourne-Sydney-Brisbane air corridor is one of the busiest in the world, and people want to be able to commute and fly between the cities,' he said.

'A lot of modern business and so forth works because of that. You're saying merely we just shouldn't do that?'

Dr Hutchinson said their phone call was an example of how long-distance communication is available in other forms, with a lot of businesses turning to video calling platforms off the back of the pandemic.

'It's not difficult to change your behaviours if you just look at the other options, and what we're encouraging people to do is to just look at the other options,' she continued.

'I went to university in the UK, and every couple of years I like to go visit old friends there - am I allowed to do that or is that not allowed?' Elliott then asked.

'I'm not making a choice for you, as for the people who have joined Flight Free Australia made that choice not to fly until it's safe to do so,' the activist said.

'One of the big problems with emissions is the aviation fuel, and aviation is one of the very few industries where we don't have an alternate means of energy.'

Elliott then asked whether Flight Free Australia would prefer if long-distance travel reverted back to using ships regardless of the drawn-out travel times.

The activist did not respond, before quietly asking 'does it sound good to you?'

'Well, not really. I don't have the time,' he laughed.

'I don't have the time to be travelling two weeks on a ship to get there. I don't think the world is like that anymore.'

'I think what we have to look at is the alternative,' Dr Hutchinson said.

'We're actually living in a climate emergency right now, and every small amount of emissions we can possibly save we really have to do. It's not a question of what we might like to do, it's a question of what we have to do.'

Commerical flights have long since been a point of contention for climate change activists, with Jean-Marc Jancovici proposing a universal quota should be imposed on air travel earlier this year.

The French engineer and climate activist said people should be limited to four long haul flights in their lifetime in order to mitigate climate change.

The call to restrict flying comes as environmentalists were slammed this week after suggesting dogs should go vegan.

Research by the University of Winchester found cats and dogs consume about 9 per cent of all land animals killed for food – about 7 billion animals annually – as well as billions of fish and aquatic animals, The Guardian reported.

**********************************************

China's growing use of coal including the LONGEST coal transporting railway - which carries 200 MILLION tons of fossil fuel 1,141 MILES annually

China continues to move hundreds of millions of tons of coal across its railway system each year, drawing ire from Western pundits as other countries are forcing citizens to 'go green' and reduce their carbon footprint.

Scottish journalist Andrew Neil recently ripped Western governments in the wake of China's projects, such as the Menghua Railway, which is the longest-coal transporting train in the world.

The 1,141-mile railway moves 200million tons of coal each year as fossil fuel use - and traditional greenhouse gas emissions - continue to skyrocket in the communist nation.

While China continues to see its demand for coal g leaders in countries such as the US and UK continue to impose restrictions on its citizens and push going green to reach 'net zero' emissions across the globe.

The Menghua Railway was built as part of China's 12th five-year plan (a series of social and economic development initiatives issued by the county's communist government to take place over a period of five years). It went into operation in late 2019.

The erection of the railway shattered several world records and has helped facilitate the transport of coal from Inner Mongolia to China's southern provinces.

The railway is the country's longest coal transporting line, and joins a large handful of Chinese coal train lines that move the fossil fuel across the country.

China burns more coal every year than the rest of the world combined, and coal accounts for more than half of the total train cargo shipped across the country annually.

While America and Europe back away from coal, China's usage has only gone up. The country has more than 1,000 coal plants despite a vow from Chinese President Xi Jinping that his country will reach net-zero emissions by 2060.

China emits somewhere around 27 percent of the world's carbon dioxide, and a third of the globe's total greenhouse gases. As Western nations struggle to implement green initiatives that may or may not impact the environment in a significant way, China has made no such effort to curb its emissions.

The Menghua Railway is just one example of a way in which China continues to use fossil fuels to power its country. Any such railroad in Europe or the US would surely attract significant backlash from activists and some politicians.

This week, Neil responded to a video from the Chinese newspaper People's Daily promoting the 1,141-mile railway that was built to transport hundreds of millions of tons of coal from north to south China each year.

He wrote to his 1.2million Twitter followers: 'But you should still swap your boiler for a heat pump to save the planet.' A facetious reference to the UK government's bans on gas boilers.

Neil's comments are a reflection of a widening brand of frustration that Westerners, whose governments are moving to impose lifestyle restrictions in the name of climate change, share.

China is in a strong global position and its power is only on the rise, while its alliances and intentions are uniformly concerning for America and Europe.

Some fear that imposing green initiatives will handicap the ability of Europe and America's citizenry and governments to produce goods, while China is rolling on full-steam ahead with production powered by fossil fuels.

Furthermore, green initiatives generally come with steep price tags, an example of which is the Biden Administration's concentration on Electric Vehicles, which most Americans cannot afford.

*****************************************************

A new Greenie racket

Federal architects of a controversial new rule requiring businesses to measure their carbon footprints throughout their supply chains have joined a start-up company poised to reap millions by performing those calculations.

At least three ranking Securities and Exchange Commission officials have joined Persefoni, a company formed in 2020 for the purpose of measuring such footprints of large business enterprises.

Documents show that the SEC relied on input from the for-profit company to draft the proposed rule. Some critics argue that the estimates from Persefoni low-balled the price tags unrealistically for such accounting to make them more politically palatable.

Persefoni, billing itself as “The Platform for Carbon Accounting – Built For Climate Disclosure,” and similar outfits are emerging as their own service industry as they stand to profit from the new rule, since most companies do not have the staff or expertise to calculate their carbon footprints.

While environmentalists have hailed the rule as an important step in forcing companies to grapple with their impact on the climate by exposing it to the public, critics argue that it goes far beyond the SEC’s core mission of protecting investors. In voting against a draft of the proposal, SEC Commissioner Hester Peirce, a Trump appointee, said it “forces investors to view companies through the eyes of a vocal set of stakeholders” – as opposed to traditional shareholders – “for whom a company’s climate reputation is of equal or greater importance than a company’s financial performance.”

The SEC and Persefoni each declined to comment for this article.

Persefoni appears to have had great influence over the proposed rule. Public records from the SEC show the commission held six meetings with representatives from Persefoni and Ceres – a prominent investor advocacy group that supports such climate disclosure – from September 2021 to June 2022.

Lee, a Democrat who joined the SEC as a staff attorney in 2005, was appointed by President Trump as one of the SEC’s five commissioners in 2019 – filling a Democratic vacancy on the commission, which was structured to be nonpartisan. President Biden named her as acting chair in 2021, and she took charge of the public comment period for the proposed rule.

Lee stepped down on March 15, 2022, just six days before the commission unveiled its proposed climate rule. In May 2023, she joined Persefoni as a member of the firm’s “sustainability advisory board.”

At Persefoni, she reunited with Kristina Wyatt, who joined the company’s board in March 2022. Previously, Wyatt had served the SEC as senior counsel for climate and environmental, social, and corporate governance (ESG). In this capacity, she worked directly on developing the proposed rule. Wyatt was also listed as the direct contact when the commission circulated a request for information from the public regarding climate-change disclosures.

In December 2022, Persefoni hired another SEC alum, Emily Pierce, to serve as associate general counsel and vice president of global regulatory climate disclosure.

By all accounts, the SEC leaned heavily on Persefoni’s cost-benefit analysis of the pending rule, which essentially establishes a parallel disclosure regime for the SEC – all in the name of mitigating climate change.

The SEC proposal has many parts, but the most controversial and cumbersome involves the requirement that larger companies must provide soup-to-nuts calculations of their carbon emissions, including those from thousands of their suppliers operating across hundreds of countries.

******************************************************

The time-bomb in your EV

Lithium-ion batteries in electric vehicles are both their biggest plus and most dangerous threat – to owners and the environment.

ABC AM interviewed Catriona Lowe, deputy chair of the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission, last Thursday to discuss the fire risk of battery charging. She was speaking after an electric scooter exploded in a fireball at a backpacker hostel in Sydney last Wednesday.

Lowe called for a government consumer awareness campaign about the dangers of lithium-ion batteries that now power everything from phones to vacuum cleaners, power tools and cars.

A few weeks earlier, on September 12, five cars were destroyed at Sydney’s Mascot Airport after a battery detached from a luxury EV ignited.

This column discussed media reporting of EVs on February 6 and on November 15, 2021, but did not mention the difficulty of extinguishing EV fires because of what firefighters call the thermal runway. Global figures make clear EV fires are rare.

But they are an issue. The specialist US motoring website hagerty.com has explained in detail why many country US race tracks are refusing to let EVs or hybrids compete. It says there are only two ways to deal with lithium-ion battery fires: “Douse a fire with water to cool it down: a lot of water, between 3000 gallons (11,356 litres) and 30,000 gallons depending on the incident. Cooling takes 100 times more water than a gasoline fire.” The other method is to let the fire burn out and then submerge the entire smouldering wreck in water.

EV batteries can be compromised in even small vehicle accidents and that is when they become dangerous. This is now feeding into soaring insurance premiums in the UK, where the Guardian and the Express newspapers have reported EV insurance premiums are set to rise by up to 1000 per cent.

The Guardian on September 30 reported on a young man who bought a Tesla Model Y. When his policy renewal fell due his insurer refused to reinsure the car. When he finally found a company that would his annual premium had risen from £1200 ($A2290) to £5000 in one year.

The Guardian mentioned the increased cost of repairing EVs but did not get to the heart of the issue.

The battery is about half the cost of a new EV and batteries that sit under the car floor are easily damaged in quite minor accidents. Repairers say fixing batteries is extremely difficult and insurers are tending to write off even quite new cars if there is even slight damage to the battery.

This was the problem with the Sydney Airport fire. The car’s battery had been damaged, and damaged batteries are more likely to catch fire.

A March 21 Reuters report written from London and Detroit says: “For many electric vehicles, there is no way to repair or even assess even slightly damaged battery packs after accidents, forcing insurance companies to write off cars with few miles … And now those battery packs are piling up in scrap yards in some countries …”

The report says the UK has no battery recycling facilities so batteries from damaged cars have to be removed and stored separately in fireproof containers.

Thatcham Research, the UK car insurance industry’s central safety research group, said EVs were 25.5 per cent more expensive to repair than normal cars and repairs took 14 per cent longer.

It identified the most significant challenge for the industry as “insurance claims originating from high-voltage battery damage”. It said batteries “represent a substantial percentage of the original vehicle value” and “negatively impact the economic model of vehicle repair … due to their cost as a percentage of the car’s market value.”

Why do motoring journalists not mention any of this? Surely buyers need to know if their new car insurance premiums are about to soar.

One senior industry figure this column spoke to said the real problem with fires in EVs was a lack of data.

He cited the potential dangers of EVs charging in parking facilities under residential buildings and the possibility fires could spread dangerous chemicals through building airconditioning systems.

A spokesman for the Insurance Council of Australia said it was too early to know what effects EV repair costs would have on premiums here but did suggest the cost of importing parts, scarcity of EV service centres and problems with battery repair and disposal would be an issue.

Taking up the challenge, Fire and Rescue NSW in July launched a two-year project called Safety of Alternative Renewable Energy Technologies looking at lithium-ion fires, end-of-life battery hazards and EV fires in structures such as parking garages.

The website EVFireSafe.com, set up by the federal government, is a good place to start if you want to understand why lithium-ion fires are difficult to control.

Yet the fire risk of batteries to owners pales when compared with the risk the manufacture, transportation, storage and disposal of used batteries poses to the global environment.

Detailed studies on carbon abatement show many EVs in the Western world charged on power grids still largely dominated by fossil fuel electricity production may take up to five years of driving to repay their manufacturing carbon deficit compared with internal combustion engine cars.

That falls to one year on grids powered by renewables or nuclear power.

This initial carbon deficit in the manufacturing stage is about 40 per cent of total vehicle life cycle emissions, according to McKinsey, and “can be attributed to the extraction and refining of raw materials like lithium, cobalt and nickel that are needed for batteries, as well as the energy-intensive nature of battery manufacture”.

Here’s the rub for planet Earth. Most EVs exported around the world, including Teslas, are made in China, and China also dominates lithium-ion battery manufacture, even for cars assembled elsewhere.

Yet China is the world’s largest emitter of CO2 and its emissions are rising faster than emissions are falling in the West.

That is, Western countries are destroying their domestic motor vehicle manufacturing industries to hand over that comparative advantage, and the corresponding jobs, to China. Yet China is lifting emissions of greenhouse gasses that EV use is designed to reduce.

There are signs consumers are wising up in the US where EV sales have fallen sharply this year, price discounting led by Tesla and Ford has spread, and more than 100,000 new EVs sit in new-car lots. Demand is still strong here.

Few journalists will write it, but it is hard to justify putting up with EV range anxiety and the extra trouble finding charging stations while still paying the large premium over conventional car prices. This is simple technology that won’t do the planet much good, at least until electricity across the world is made without emissions. And the mining of many of the rare earths needed to make batteries is dangerous in some poor countries, both for the people working in mines and for the environment.

EVs, with instant torque and a low centre of gravity, are fun to drive. Not much can go wrong with them, maintenance is generally cheap and they make sense for city driving when constant stopping helps battery recharge.

Just don’t do anything to damage your battery.

***************************************

My other blogs. Main ones below

http://dissectleft.blogspot.com (DISSECTING LEFTISM )

http://edwatch.blogspot.com (EDUCATION WATCH)

http://pcwatch.blogspot.com (POLITICAL CORRECTNESS WATCH)

http://australian-politics.blogspot.com (AUSTRALIAN POLITICS)

http://snorphty.blogspot.com/ (TONGUE-TIED)

http://jonjayray.com/blogall.html More blogs

*****************************************